No Sweetness Here by Ama Ata Aidoo NOT Fit for Study as Core Literature Textbook

20160209_161710.jpg

The book No Sweetness Here and Other Stories by Ama Atta Aidoo is an anthology of short stories heavily embedded in transliterations with varied thematic concerns. It is a book that needs higher minds to read, understand and appreciate. I was baffled when it was approved by the Ghana Education Service as a core text for the study of literature in senior high schools in Ghana; a core text! Not an elective text!

At first I thought I was paranoid until my colleague teachers and other English teachers I came into contact with complained about the fact that the text was not a readable text for core study and the students themselves brought their sad opinions. In their own words “The book’s title is an exact reflection of its content Madam” Students of core Literature are mostly students who need exciting books, straightforward books with searchable thematic concerns in order to understand the ways of literature and get familiar with the use of the literary terms.

From Everything Counts to The Message right through to Other Versions are punishment for these beginners. Many are those who suspect foul in the selection. This is no Grief Child or Ancestral Sacrifice?

I call for those who approved this text to read the content and come up with another book. They can make it an elective text as those students study deep into literature and can understand. As a core text, it is not only a punishment to students but to teachers as well as we have to find ways of getting weak readers interested in such a text. We are in Ghana where a teacher teaches over 250 students in a term. What can we do if we have to chase most of these students to read? Let’s put into consideration the fact that the prose text is just a little fraction of the things to be taught.

The Ghana Education Service must look seriously into this and rectify the error if it is. If it is not, then they should come out with the criteria they used in selecting this book in particular, that is, if it is not to give purchase to the known writer or a battle of publishers and bids. Let us consider the students who will be affected by the study of such a text. Let us also consider the fact that we do not have a reading generation and the many people trying to inculcate the habit of reading in today’s youth. At least, let the children read stories that will lead them to uncover the gateway to life’s beauties not stories which they will be coaxed or punished to read. Textbooks are read by sizes of the mind. God bless our homeland Ghana.

Amoafowaa Sefa Cecilia (c) 2016

 

4 thoughts on “No Sweetness Here by Ama Ata Aidoo NOT Fit for Study as Core Literature Textbook

  1. I wish to disagree. There’s nothing heavy about this anthology that requires ‘higher minds to read’ and understand the themes embedded in the book. If kids in Senior High School can’t read and understand this beautiful book, then they have no business being in school.
    Plus, isn’t it the duty of the teacher to help the kids appreciate the book and its themes that reflect the Ghanaian society?

    Like

    1. That is your view. But I was tested on one of the stories at the university. This is a story that is not, and I repeat not suitable for core reading, maybe elective but not core. If you are objective enough, you will see that the beautiful book as you call it, is heavily embedded in transliterations which boarder on the Akan language. Even reading this to make children who are not Akans is difficult enough. We need students to love reading and this book is not a good way to start. Re-read the book again, think of the different learners and capabilities in shs and not the best literary students and come again.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. It’s important to introduce children and young minds to the joys of reading, and not to make it such a chore. As you state, it will lead them to uncover life’s beauties, but only if the initial experience is a positive one.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s